Indonesian Court Overturns Record $45 Million Fines Against Online Lenders

Indonesian Court Overturns Record $45 Million Fines Against Online Lenders
Photo: Asia Times 27.10.2026 1060

A Jakarta court ruled that the lenders’ interest-rate cap followed regulatory instructions rather than an illegal cartel agreement.

A Jakarta court has overturned a record 755 billion rupiah ($45 million) in fines imposed on 97 online lenders in Indonesia for allegedly fixing interest rates, finding that the industry's lending-rate ceiling followed instructions from the financial regulator rather than an unlawful agreement among competitors.

The Central Jakarta Commercial Court also found that the maximum rate did not constitute price fixing, that conventional and Sharia-compliant lending belonged to different markets and that the competition regulator had failed to establish an agreement among competing lenders.

Indonesian Competition Commission, or KPPU, spokesman Deswin Nur told MLex on Monday that the regulator had not yet decided whether to pursue further legal action.

"We respect the court's decision on this matter. We are still studying the outcome and have not decided on the next steps," 

Deswin said.

The Indonesian Joint Funding Fintech Association, or AFPI, welcomed the ruling, maintaining that the disputed interest-rate ceiling had been introduced at the direction of the Financial Services Authority, or OJK, to protect borrowers from predatory lending and excessive borrowing costs.

"From the outset, we maintained that we were only following the regulator's instructions," 

AFPI Chairman Kuseryansyah said in a statement sent to MLex.

The decision, delivered Thursday by a panel chaired by Judge Anton Rizal Setiawan, overturns the KPPU's March 26 ruling that 97 online lenders had violated Indonesia's prohibition on price fixing through an industry-wide ceiling on daily lending rates. The decision, which imposed the largest aggregate fine in the regulator's history, was subsequently challenged before the Commercial Court

The court's decision raises questions about the boundaries between financial-sector regulation and competition-law enforcement, particularly when companies follow regulatory instructions implemented through an industry association.

Compliance or cartel?

The central issue was whether the AFPI’s interest-rate ceiling — a maximum daily interest rate of 0.8 percent outlined in a code of conduct applied between October 2018 and March 2024 — constituted an agreement among competitors or compliance with instructions from the regulator responsible for supervising the industry.

The court sided with the lenders. It found that the OJK had exercised its regulatory discretion in directing the industry to establish maximum interest rates, even though no explicit regulation governed the arrangement at the time, according to court spokesman Sunoto, who outlined the judges' reasoning in a statement Friday.

The judges accepted testimony that the OJK had authority under its governing legislation to direct the introduction of the ceiling. Applying the state action doctrine, the court found that the ceiling reflected government regulatory action rather than an independent agreement among lenders.

According to a summary of the judgment obtained by MLex, the court found that the OJK had actively supervised compliance with its instructions through regulatory correspondence and the threat of sanctions.

The judges also found insufficient evidence of an unlawful agreement among the lenders. Not every AFPI member had participated in adopting the ceiling, while compliance with the policy was influenced by OJK's instructions and the threat of sanctions, the court found.

Those circumstances did not establish the concerted action required to prove an unlawful agreement among competitors, the court found.

The finding is consistent with testimony reported by MLex in November 2025, when a senior OJK official told the KPPU that the regulator had encouraged AFPI to introduce an interest-rate ceiling as part of a light-touch approach to supervising the emerging online lending industry.

The OJK initially relied on the association's code of conduct to limit lending rates before introducing its own regulatory requirements in late 2023. The KPPU, however, argued during the appeal that government involvement and the existence of a maximum rate did not automatically shield companies from prosecution for price fixing.

Kuseryansyah said the ruling provided legal certainty for online lenders by recognizing that compliance with regulatory instructions did not constitute a competition-law violation in this case. The AFPI would continue promoting responsible lending practices and stronger industry governance, he added.

Price ceiling, not price fixing 

The court also rejected the KPPU's characterization of the interest-rate ceiling as an unlawful pricing agreement.

Sunoto said the judges distinguished between a ceiling, which limits the maximum interest rate lenders may charge, and price fixing, which involves competitors agreeing to determine prices.

The court found that the AFPI's policy established a maximum rate rather than requiring all lenders to charge identical rates. Evidence showed that lenders charged different rates depending on borrowers' circumstances and credit profiles.

The KPPU had argued in June that an industry-wide ceiling could serve as a focal point for implicit coordination, even without an explicit agreement to charge identical rates. The regulator maintained that a maximum rate established collectively by competitors could influence their independent pricing decisions and reduce competition.

The court separately rejected the KPPU's treatment of conventional online lending and Sharia-compliant financing as part of the same relevant market. The judges found that the two financing models had different characteristics and were not sufficiently interchangeable.

As a result, the KPPU had failed to establish the relevant market required to prove price fixing under Article 5 of Indonesia's competition law.

The court's decision annuls fines ranging from 1 billion rupiah to 102.3 billion rupiah. Fifty-two lenders had received the minimum penalty, while AdaKami was handed the largest fine.

The court also ordered the KPPU to pay approximately 23.6 million rupiah in court costs.

In announcing the verdict, the judges called for stronger coordination between government authorities to prevent conflicting regulatory requirements, saying businesses should not be penalized for implementing policies imposed by their regulators.

Source: MLex

digital markets  fintech  Indonesia 

Share with friends

Related content